• Home
  • Mission
  • Noahide Laws
    • The 7 Laws >
      • The 7 Laws
      • Connection to the Ten Commandments
    • Universal Morality >
      • Universal Morality
      • Belief in G-d and His Moral Values
    • Government Leaders and the Seven Noahide Laws
  • Contact
  • Understanding the Code
  • Funding Morality
J.I.F.G.A.

Murder/ Killing: Endangering Oneself or Another

There is no transgression more severe, and more injurious to civilization and society, than the killing of innocent human beings.  This does not mean that human life is an absolute and there are no circumstances in which life may, and even should be, taken.  In general, however, killing is the gravest of acts.  The other Noahide laws treat facets of human existence: one's relationship to nature, to material property and claims to justice in the realm of human relationships; and to aspects of personal moral identity in the person's relationship with G-d.  The transgression of murder, however, takes away human existence itself, upon which all these relationships are predicated.  Whilst one is alive, one can affect the world at some level- physical, mental or spiritual or even through the response of others to one's own situation.  (Even where the human being is not responsive (at the level of thought, speech or action, all of which are significant), we cannot judge the value of the spiritual presence which that person's existence represents; as well as, in the case of a profoundly disabled human being, the elicitation of qualities in others which that person's presence providentially achieves.) The deprivation of life is the foreclosure of that possibility.  The Divine intention in creation is that it is specifically in the hands of the human being peacefully to inhabit the world and to reveal G-dliness within it for the benefit of all creatures.  In terms of this purpose, killing results in the very creation itself losing a fundamental aspect of its reason for being.  The Tradition moreover states: "Whoever spills blood is considered as though lessening the Divine... Why?... 'For in the image of G-d, the [soul of the] human being was created.'"  (B'reishis Rabbo 34:20)

The great severity of the transgression of killing is expressed in several unique features of this prohibition.  The first is in the victims or objects of killing for which a person may be liable.  Apart from the obvious prohibition of killing a viable human life, one is liable, under Noahide law, for killing a fetus.  The novelty here is that even though this is a dependent and "incomplete" human being, one is liable for its destruction, just as for the killing of an independent person.  This expresses the idea that human life, even when it lacks autonomy, must be protected.  Even when it is "mere" human potentiality, the basis for something "more", which will only emerge through fundamental growth and direction, and is now only a secondary and dependent existence, it needs protection.  So also with the person, faced by incurable illness, or who is dying- whose existence is without a substantial future and is dependent- one who destroys such a life, is liable for the transgression of killing.  This is because Noahide law makes the protection and the maintenance of life paramount.  

Rabbi Dr. Shimon Cowen, The Theory & Practice of Universal Ethics: The Noahide Laws, Institute for Judaism and Civilization, Melbourne & New York, 2014, pgs. 290-291.

Home

Mission

Contact

Copyright © 2018-2019
  • Home
  • Mission
  • Noahide Laws
    • The 7 Laws >
      • The 7 Laws
      • Connection to the Ten Commandments
    • Universal Morality >
      • Universal Morality
      • Belief in G-d and His Moral Values
    • Government Leaders and the Seven Noahide Laws
  • Contact
  • Understanding the Code
  • Funding Morality